The League You Can’t Watch

Photo: Krzysztof Popławski, via Wikimedia Commons CC BY 4.0

Tonight I watched Canada play Guatemala on TNT — actual television, a stadium in Toronto that looked full from what I could see — and it struck me how rare that sentence is. A soccer match, on a channel, where anybody flipping past could land on it. It almost never happens with our own league, and that’s not an accident. That’s a choice somebody made.

Start with the game itself, because the game is not the problem. Soccer moves. It starts, it runs 45 minutes, there’s a short halftime, it runs 45 more, and it’s done in about two hours. You can talk through it, glance up every so often, and still know exactly what’s going on, because there’s a thread and the thread never stops. There are no commercial breaks carved into the middle of it. The clock runs, the ball runs, and so does the match.

Compare the game we call football. The feet touch the ball for punts, kickoffs, field goals and extra points — that’s the whole list. The thing they throw isn’t even a ball; it’s a rugby-shaped object with laces. A game takes three, three and a half hours, and the ball is actually in play for something like eleven minutes of it. The rest is standing around — forty seconds of huddle between plays, which in any other sport would count as a timeout. I am not saying it isn’t entertaining. I am saying that if flow were the test, the test was rigged from the start.

So why isn’t soccer bigger in this country? It isn’t the game. It’s the carriage. Television here is built on commercial breaks, and soccer doesn’t stop for them — two halves and one halftime is all the inventory a network gets. For decades, that was reason enough to keep the game off the air, and a sport nobody can watch is a sport nobody follows. That’s not a mystery. That’s arithmetic.

History proves the mechanism. When my dad was a kid, it was baseball, baseball, baseball — the number one sport in America for years and years. Football didn’t overtake it by being better. Television overtook it. Sunday appointment viewing, week after week, the Super Bowl arriving in the late sixties, the same game in the same slot until a whole country built its Sundays around it. Exposure builds audiences. It always has. Nobody becomes a fan of something they’ve never seen.

Which is what makes what Major League Soccer did so hard to understand. In 2023 the league put every match behind Apple’s paywall — a separate subscription, on top of a subscription, ten years and two and a half billion dollars of guaranteed money. I understand why they took it. But understand what it cost: nobody could stumble onto it. You cannot channel-surf into a paywall. The casual viewer, the one who becomes a fan by accident on a Saturday afternoon, never saw a single match. The league sold the discovery that built every other sport in this country, and it sold it for a floor price.

And then — this is the part I like — they admitted it. The separate subscription is gone now. The matches ride inside an ordinary Apple TV subscription, the deal ends years early, and viewership reportedly jumped by more than half once the wall came down. The commissioner said it out loud: they’d do the same deal again, other than the subscription. That’s this whole rant in one sentence, from the man who signed the deal.

Meanwhile, look at the women. The National Women’s Soccer League put its games on CBS, ESPN, Amazon and Scripps — real television, in the open, including fifty Saturday-night matches on Scripps alone. Four years, about 240 million dollars, and a bet on being seen. Which is why, domestically, you now come across the women’s game on TV more than the men’s. They took the prescription the men’s league sold.

The game sells itself wherever people can see it. Toronto was full tonight. Canada sent this blog ten readers today, third behind China and the United States, which still surprises me a little. Put MLS on Saturdays — afternoon, evening, regular as church, the way the women’s league already does it — and watch what happens. It worked for football seventy years ago. It’s working for the women right now. The only league that ever doubted it was the one that took the money instead of the audience.

Read more:

  • MLS and Apple: the original deal, and the renegotiation that dropped the paywall — FourFourTwo and Gadget Hacks
  • The NWSL’s four-year deal with CBS, ESPN, Amazon and Scripps — ESPN

Leave a Reply