
The video that started this one isn’t from a trade journal. It’s a woman on a farm, on a channel called Becoming a Farm Girl, noticing something from her kitchen table: Americans are refusing to upgrade — phones, cars, appliances — and the companies built on the replacement treadmill didn’t see it coming. Kitchen-table observations are usually wrong in the particulars. This one has numbers behind it.
Start with phones, where the measuring is cleanest. Assurant tracks the American trade-in stream, and the age of a phone when its owner finally trades it in keeps setting records on the same measuring stick: in the second quarter of 2025 it hit 3.88 years, the oldest since the company has kept the series. The attitude behind the number is in Allstate Protection Plans’ 2025 mobile survey: about one in five Americans now waits until the phone actually breaks before replacing it. The two-year upgrade, once the industry’s default rhythm, is no longer the default.
Cars tell the same story at a bigger ticket. S&P Global Mobility puts the average light vehicle on American roads at a record 12.8 years old in 2025 — while the average new vehicle changed hands at $50,080 last September, also a record. People aren’t keeping old cars because they love old cars. The replacement is priced like a second mortgage, and the old one still runs.
Appliances complete the picture, and here the interesting finding is that the willingness to repair was never the problem. A seven-country study by the Nuremberg Institute for Market Decisions found large majorities everywhere wanting appliances built easier to repair, with saving money over buying new as the top reason to fix rather than replace. The gate is arithmetic: a real repair often costs more than people judge a repair to be worth against the price of new. The desire is there. The numbers on the repair bill are what say no.
Fairness requires the other half, and it’s a real half. The treadmill has slowed, not stopped: trade-in programs returned a record sum to American consumers in 2025, because people do still upgrade — later, and expecting value for the old device when they do. And the makers have quietly lengthened the leash themselves: flagship phones from Google and Samsung now carry seven years of software updates, which is an admission that the hardware is expected to stay in the same hands that long. “Didn’t see it coming” is the video’s frame. What the record shows is an industry adjusting, a step behind its customers.
The rule at this house is simpler than any of the studies: a phone is just a phone, and you replace it when it stops doing the job it is for. The current one is a refurbished phone that cost a fraction of flagship money, and it will be replaced on the same terms — when it quits, not when a keynote says so. Common sense, which isn’t very common anymore.
Read more
- The phone numbers: Assurant, Mobile Trade-In and Upgrade Industry Trends Reports — the trade-in age series (record 3.88 years, Q2 2025) and the full-year report (a record $6.4 billion returned through trade-ins in 2025) — https://smartphones.gadgethacks.com/news/smartphone-upgrade-cycles-hit-3-4-years-what-changed/
- The attitude: Allstate Protection Plans, 2025 Mobile Survey — 21% wait until the phone breaks; 23% stretch to three or four years.
- The car numbers: S&P Global Mobility, “U.S. Vehicle Age Rises Again to 12.8 Years in 2025”; Kelley Blue Book / Cox Automotive — average new-vehicle transaction price, $50,080, September 2025.
- The repair picture: Nuremberg Institute for Market Decisions, “Repair or Buy New?” (seven countries, 14,000 adults, 2025) — over 75% in every country want appliances easier to repair; Americans will pay roughly 15% of the new price for a repair. U.S. polling reported by iFixit (YouGov / Data for Progress): 71% favor right-to-repair laws.
- The video that started it: Becoming a Farm Girl, “Americans Are Refusing to Upgrade, and Companies Didn’t See It Coming” (YouTube, Nov 16, 2026) — https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PjBdoqSHliM — spark only; none of its figures are used here.