Is the Christmas Holiday Constitutional?

 

267B902A-8272-4636-9D69-132E1C598E7B

One question I never seem to hear from anyone this time of year is should we, in the U.S., actually have designated a holiday for Christmas? Think about it, it’s a sectarian celebration, and with the federal government designating December 25th as a national holiday, are they not in fact in violation of the Establishment Clause of the 1st Amendment?

No other major (or minor) religion has any day or days designated as national holidays  and even to Christians up until the holiday was esablished in 1870 viewed the celebration as being un-Christian.  The church didn’t even officially recognize December 25th until sometime in the mid fourth century, and there’s dispute among scholars as to why that specific date was chosen.

Although it may seem unfair to other religious beliefs that Congress would pass a bill recognizing Christmas as a holiday, it wasn’’t done in any way that would recognize the actual religious belief. The bill covered both December 25th and January 1st  and the language used in the bill only referred to each date as being commonly known as  Christmas and New Years Day and did not endorse any religious celebration. As far as I have been able to ascertain, there has never been a constitutional challenge for December 25th as being designated Christmas, even though the origin was explicitly religious in nature.

So, it’s not unconstitutional on its face because there is nothing that specifies any sectarian worship on the particular day and nothing in the law that was passed says anything about it being about any particular religious tradition. People celebrate the day the way they want: some do in fact go to church while for others it’s a day of family, food, and gifts to one another.

There may be some that don’t like the idea that the government recognizes this day at all, but as long as the same does not officially endorse it religiously, there’s nothing wrong with having a holiday known as Christmas.

2 thoughts on “Is the Christmas Holiday Constitutional?

  1. Good point. By making Christmas (a religious celebration) a National holiday the Government is supporting the Christian religion. Suggestion: The significant thing about mid December is the winter solstice. How about a turning of the Sun holiday, to celebrate the nights getting shorter? GROG

    Like

  2. The word origin is ‘Christ Mass.’ Many C’s don’t even go to church on the 25th anymore. Such a joke. Too much goin’ on at home. When I visited Independence Hall (in Philly), they said those founding fathers worked on Christmas Day because they did not do that. Christmas was a European thing and we were trying to get away from all of that. I do not have a problem with the holiday…I kind of see it as secular, as I do others. It is prolly not supposed to be, but it will not be changed.
    But why (I gotta ask) do C’s find it necessary to display the damn cross (His death device) on Christmas? It’s like “Hay baby J., this is where you’re headed lad.” Hangman’s noose or guillotine anyone? I don’t get that.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s