Israel voted on Tuesday, in the highest turnout since 1999 — 77.7 percent, per the Central Elections Committee — and produced the one result nobody on either side wanted to say out loud: a deadlock. The exit polls put Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s bloc and the opposition bloc led by former military chief Gadi Eisenkot at roughly 51 seats each in the 120-seat Knesset, with Arab-led parties holding about 18. Two days of counting have since moved the seats around — with more than nine in ten ballots counted, Netanyahu’s bloc stands at 53, the opposition at 48, the Arab-led parties at 19 — without moving the conclusion. Sixty-one seats form a government. Nobody has them.
That is the result the speeches were given over. What the two men did with it is the story.
Eisenkot spoke first, to his own supporters, and claimed the meaning of the night if not the arithmetic. “The people decided in favor of change,” he said. “This will be a real new beginning, a new era. The old era has ended.” He said a true leader, facing these numbers, “would have decided to resign and accept the will of the people.” Then he delivered the line that will follow Netanyahu into whatever negotiations come next: “Netanyahu, do not dare to use Israel’s security to achieve your own purposes and political interests.” He urged the security forces and the police to stand firm during the transition. The Associated Press noted what everyone in the room understood — the warning was a reference to reports, in the final days before the vote, that Netanyahu had considered a strike on Iran timed against the election calendar. Eisenkot’s own promises ran the other direction: military service mandatory for everyone — “the era of evading military service is over,” a direct shot at the ultra-Orthodox draft exemptions that prop up Netanyahu’s coalition — and the dismantling of Hamas rule in Gaza.
Netanyahu spoke after 3 a.m. in Jerusalem, and claimed a different country than the exit polls described. His Likud party, he said, is “the largest party and nobody can compete with us” — on that much, the polls agree; Likud is projected first, with roughly 24 to 27 seats. Then came the arithmetic to watch. The right-wing bloc, Netanyahu declared, had won a decisive majority. As the Times of Israel reported it, the majority he named was a majority of the “Zionist public” — a count that simply sets aside the 19 seats the count now gives the Arab-led parties, nearly one voter in six, and declares victory among the remainder. He called for “a strong, right-wing, nationalist government,” ruled out any government resting on Arab parties — “against our existence” — and, per Ynet, opened a campaign against the legitimacy of any government formed with their support. He attacked the television channels for projections he said discouraged his voters, and the “criminal political investigations” against him. What he did not do, in this speech, is claim the election was stolen. The grievance was aimed at the media and the prosecutors, not the count.
And then he turned to Iran, as Eisenkot had known he would. “Iran is weaker than ever, Israel is stronger than ever,” he said, and together with “our partner President Trump,” Israel faced a historic opportunity “to remove the Iranian threat once and for all.”
So both men, on the same night, put Iran at the center of what comes next — one accusing the other of nearly spending it on an election, the other promising to finish it with American help. The war question did not wait for a government. It was the government question.
Where it goes from here is process, and process favors the man already in the chair. President Herzog, in his first remarks since the polls closed, said he will receive the official results next week — they are due by November 4 — consult the factions, and urged an “open mind” to avoid another election. He will then assign one of them the first attempt at forming a government: 28 days, with a possible 14-day extension. Until a new government is sworn in, Netanyahu remains prime minister, and a long deadlock leaves him there, as caretaker, while the arithmetic refuses to move. The kingmaker math is cold for both sides in a colder way than election night suggested: on paper, the opposition plus the Arab-led parties reaches 67 — a governing number that exists only on paper. Netanyahu has barred that door from his side, and Eisenkot built his campaign on a “Zionist majority,” a formula that shuts out the Joint List while leaving Ra’am — whose leader, Mansour Abbas, has accepted Israel as a Jewish and democratic state — technically eligible. Abbas said on election night that he was talking to both blocs and was open to Eisenkot — but, in his own words, “there aren’t numbers.” He meant it politically. Every count since has proved him right.
Two speeches, one deadlock. Neither man claimed victory, as Reuters put it flatly. Both claimed the future. Since then the ballots have been counted in tranches — exit polls, the first real count, the late envelopes — and every count has delivered the same verdict: a government for nobody. The speeches were arguments about a country that, on the numbers, does not exist yet. The count belongs to nobody.
Read more
On the exit polls and the count:
- Reuters — Netanyahu and Eisenkot stake rival claims after a deadlocked vote
- Associated Press — voters rebuke Netanyahu, exit polls show no clear winner
On the speeches:
- NPR — turnout soars as Netanyahu faces a tight election
- The Times — Netanyahu buoyed, though no clear winner yet
On what comes next: