
I got up this morning, turned on YouTube to watch my two Sunday renovation shows, and the first thing in my face was Wes Huff. Again. Somebody I’d never heard of, with a brand-new take on Wes Huff. Then another one. A preacher is now blaming Marxists for the plagiarism allegations, which tells you how far around the bend this thing has gone. So before I get to my shows, let me say my piece — because this is going to be my last piece on the subject for a while, and I mean that.
Here is what Wes Huff needs to do. He needs to own it. Period.
Not “I’m not that person from ten years ago.” Not “it was a rough draft.” Just this: I did it. I’m guilty of it. I’m sorry I did it. That’s the whole statement. Everything else he’s said so far has been varnish, and everybody watching can see the grain through it.
Instead of owning it, he fell on the sword of the friendliest audience he could find — his pastor, his church’s elder board, the board of Apologetics Canada, the outfit he works for. I’m sure they’re all very nice people. They are also not the people who decide this. A formal complaint has been filed with his university, and that changes who owns this case. The people at the university now have to go through his submitted work line by line — not just the one paper everybody’s seen, but the work from his other classes too — and find out whether this was one bad paper or a pattern. Then they make the determination. Up to and including, if it comes to that, whether his master’s degree stands.
And until they do, here is my advice to everybody else in this story: shut up about it.
The defenders aren’t helping him. I watched a video last night — a small channel, BabylonBibi — that played clip after clip of Huff’s defenders, and every single one of them opened by attacking Dan McClellan and never got around to the evidence. That’s called poisoning the well, and you do it when the water is the one thing you can’t afford to have anybody taste. The “poor Wes” chorus does him no good at all. Neither do the pile-on artists on the other side. Nobody’s mind is being changed by the fifteenth commentary video of the weekend, and none of it will matter when the university rules. Wait for the determination. Then say whatever you have to say, based on what they found.
That’s what I’m going to do. This is my last word on Wes Huff until the university makes its call. When it does, I’ll run a paragraph or two — here’s what happened — and then we’re done with it forever. The only thing that could bring me back sooner is something huge, and by huge I mean the determination itself.
One more thing, and it’s the thing that actually bothers me most. I feel bad for Dan McClellan.
He didn’t go hunting for this. By his own account, he was searching on a topic, read something of Huff’s, and something in it set off the alarm — and anybody who has been through real academic work knows that alarm, the feeling that the voice on the page changes halfway down it. So he checked. That’s not a vendetta; that’s what you’re supposed to do. And for his trouble, he’s being guilted — including over Huff’s daughter, which Huff himself raised. McClellan opened his last video apologizing for not knowing about the girl’s situation. How was he supposed to know? What are people expected to do — take a survey of a man’s private family circumstances before they’re allowed to report what they found in his published work? It’s an awful thing to lay on a man whose entire offense was finding something and saying so. It’s not his fault Wes Huff plagiarized. He just happened to be the one reading when it surfaced.
And if the stories now coming out are true — that people in that world knew about this years ago and kept it to themselves — then those people own a piece of this too. Handled back then, quietly, the way institutions are supposed to handle it, this would have been over before Huff ever became a celebrity, and there’d be nothing to explode. Silence protected him right up until it couldn’t.
This is what happens when the conclusion comes first. An apologist is not a scholar. A scholar starts with the evidence and goes where it leads. An apologist starts with the answer and builds the evidence around it, and when the building is the job, the temptation to borrow somebody else’s bricks is always there. That’s why this makes the whole enterprise look bad — not one man’s fall, but how many people looked the other way on the way up.
So: own it, Wes. Everybody else, wait for the university. And me — I’m done until they rule. Now I’m going to go watch my renovation shows.
Read more
- Wes Huff Has Gone Dark — our original post, with the updates as they’ve come in
- The Deformed Defenders of DARK WES — BabylonBibi Beyond Satire, on the defenders’ playbook