Do I Actually Need Another Site to Hold Debates/Discussions?




Gretchen, over at SkepticReview wants me to create an account over at something called “”. It’s a place, to allow  people want to have a debate or discussion, can talk to each other, in a blog post format ( actually, a “letter” to the person you’re responding to on a particular topic. It’s a great idea, and Ive been thinking about creating an account there. Then, I thought differently. My thought is how this would, in any way, drive traffic to this blog. It may, but I need more information.

What I write about here is what I think about. In a couple of cases, with Gretchen,  these thoughts have turned into a back-and-forth discussion (not really debates in the formal sense) on some story in the news or just a topic we’ve both been interested in discussing between ourselves abd have the public view what we each think., All good, and a place like would enhance those discussions simply because all of the text is in one place; no one needs to go from my site to hers, then back again, to see who is saying what and if there is one argument that may appear better than another.

My question comes back to this site. Would I really need it anymore? I usually write once per day and if I post the same information in two places, where are the readers)you) going to go?  Now of course not all content is going to be posted on the other site, but if there’s a a discussion/debate going on, who’s going to come to my site to keep up with it? It comes down to, in those cases, something called views. Like any blogger, I look at the numbers on this site. It helps me determine a number of things including if I’m writing about something people are interested in reading. If there’s another site, whether it’s occasional or not, will those same readers come here, or will they go to the other site first?

How many different sites should someone have to come to read what I write? If I’m having a discussion/debate on one, do I then have to write other content to keep people coming back here? Will they? I don’t know and that’s the conundrum for me in creating accounts on other sites for long form opinion.

I earn nothing from this site. Notice there are no ads here., I tried that for a bit but didn’t like it. Why? I didn’t want to look like some others whose entire sites are filled with advertisements. I don’t really need the money, but my initial thought was that maybe ads would pay for the site itself. I decided, after a while, this was a bad idea and would possibly make me look too much  as someone that only wrote for money.

I’d rather quit this medium altogether than be thought of that way. I still, however, would like to see more viewers here than another place. You, my readers, keep me engaged to write. If some of that went to another site, then why would you ever want to come here? I can do this, or I can do this and other platforms as well. I think, overall, I’ll sacrifice debating on another platform than give this up.

4 thoughts on “Do I Actually Need Another Site to Hold Debates/Discussions?

  1. Agreed, altho if you link to other posts on your site, it might actually create new readers? Plus, they have a bit of a larger reach and an interesting mix of people from all over the world. I will report back on whether I think it helps or not.


    • Good f0or them. None of what you said makes me want to participate. I can always link, within a blog ( and do!) to other posts. Don’t need. Don;’ want., can’t find a reason to participate at all.


  2. In my experience, time you invest writing on other platforms generally doesn’t help your blog. If you are writing elsewhere, you aren’t writing here.


  3. Thinking that you were already set to close this blog, and being in the process of losing my old Christian debate forum, where I have been the token atheist for many years, I went searching for a forum or blog suited to an older and mellowed atheist with Conservative leanings. I have been depressed for a couple of days…

    I know there isn’t much debate here, but your blog is a place, where I feel (I can’t believe I am going to write this) safe in expressing my opinions and thoughts. The idea of venturing into those atheist forums made me sick to my stomach. Maybe I am just tired. I like The Atheist Conservative for news and opinion. Your blog is different, more personal; “different but good.” That’s a family motto.

    How many views do you get per day? Is it worth it to your “soul” to write for people who read but never comment? Is it worth it to you to just have a place where you put your thoughts out there for whomever or nobody? Do you write for yourself or do you really want dialogue and debate? Will you be replying more to those at the other site and thus defending your opinions? Will that be more stress than you want?

    There, for what it’s worth.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s