
Some of my fellow conservatives talk about Ronald Reagan the way people used to talk about saints. I’m half surprised they’re not wearing, instead of a crucifix, a tiny gold Reagan bust on a chain, or a little medal with his profile on it. A group has spent thirty years trying to get something named after him in every state and every county in the country — an airport, an aircraft carrier, some 170 dedications around the world the last time anyone counted. Among Republicans, he’s still the greatest president of their lifetimes, going away.
I know he wasn’t that great of a president. I was there.
Let me grant the first thing first, because it’s true: the relief was real. Reagan followed Jimmy Carter — gas lines, a misery index, and mortgage rates that punished ordinary buyers. My first house, bought in California in 1980, carried a 13.5 percent fixed rate, and I took it gladly, because the other bet on offer was a teaser rate that ballooned in five years and assumed you could always sell. After that era, Reagan landing in the White House felt like a breath of fresh air — because it was one. Breath of fresh air, yes. Second coming, no. He definitely wasn’t, not even close.
I watched the worship start before there was anything to worship. When he was sworn in, in January of 1981, I was living in California and working in the oil business, for a company that was very pro-Reagan. The older guys in the office — men ten, fifteen years older than me — treated anything negative about Reagan as a no-no. If you didn’t like the guy, you kept your mouth shut. I didn’t dislike him; I barely knew anything about him except that he’d been an actor. But he had only just been elected, he hadn’t done a single thing yet, and already he was, as we used to say, the greatest thing since bar soap. The reverence came first. The record was fitted around it afterward.
Because here is the record, starting with the legend’s centerpiece. “Reagan cut taxes” — did he really? The first half of the sentence is true: the 1981 act was the largest tax cut on record, and the top rate came down from 70 to 50. What got left in the drawer is that he then signed eleven major tax increases. The 1982 increase was the largest peacetime tax increase to that date. The gas tax more than doubled. Bruce Bartlett, an economist who worked in that administration, ran the numbers from Reagan’s own last budget: the increases took back about half the 1981 cut by 1988. Federal receipts over the whole “tax revolt” went from 19.6 percent of the economy to 18.4 — barely a point — and the payroll tax, the one that hits wages from the first dollar, actually rose. It was true in the beginning. Then it stopped being true, and nobody updated the legend.
The 1986 tax reform is remembered as the second great cut — top rate down to 28. What paid for it was killing the deductions ordinary families actually used: interest on car loans and credit cards, the sales-tax deduction, the two-earner deduction, income averaging, the open IRA deduction, the preference for capital gains. Fairness requires one sentence here: the reform was built to be revenue-neutral, and the average family’s bill did fall. But specific families permanently lost specific deductions, in exchange for rates — and only the rates got remembered. The losses were never restored and never mourned. A piece of one of them finally came back last year, when the new tax law let people deduct some car-loan interest again — for four years, only on cars assembled here, and phasing out once you earn too much. Trump brought back a piece of what Reagan took away, briefly, with conditions.
And then there’s the chapter the worship skips entirely. In November 1986, Reagan signed a law that legalized about 2.7 million people who were in this country illegally. His words at the signing were that they would step into the sunlight and could ultimately become Americans. Two years earlier he had used the word himself: “I believe in the idea of amnesty for those who have put down roots.” The employer sanctions that were supposed to be the law’s keystone were built to fail — papers only had to look genuine, and nobody ever built a system to check — and the unauthorized population roughly tripled in the years after. I happen to think that if a president did that today, the same people polishing the bust would be first in line to impeach him. Reagan did it, and the bust stays polished.
So why does the legend survive its own ledger? Because of the one thing the worship gets right and understands wrong. Reagan was, by a distance, the most eloquent president of my lifetime — and he was eloquent the way an actor is eloquent, because he was one, trained for thirty years to deliver other men’s words so that audiences believed them and felt what he wanted them to feel. Before politics there was radio baseball recreated off wire copy, more than fifty films, and eight years touring General Electric’s plants — 139 of them, a quarter of a million employees spoken to, a quarter of every year on the road. That road show is where “the Speech” came from. He wasn’t a puppet — “tear down this wall” survived seven attempts by his own staff to cut it because Reagan insisted — but a great delivery is a craft, and the worship keeps mistaking the best-produced part of the presidency for the presidency. If he’d been plain Ronald Reagan from Illinois, a nobody who’d climbed up through state politics, the same record would have earned him a respectful paragraph in the history books. The actor got a shrine.
And he’s not the only one it happened to, which tells you it’s not really about him. Barack Obama was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize in his first year as president — nominations had closed less than two weeks after his inauguration — before he had done anything in foreign policy at all. The left did with Obama exactly what my office did with Reagan. Reverence first, record later, if ever.
The shrine may not even stay his. In one 2021 poll, Republicans asked to name their best president picked Donald Trump over Reagan, 36 to 18. The devotion is changing hands without the conservatism changing at all — which tells you what the object was for. A record can be audited. A relic can’t. That’s why relics get built.
So no, don’t melt the bust down. Just stop genuflecting to it. Reagan was a president with a mixed ledger — a real cut and eleven increases, real relief after Carter and a real amnesty after that, a once-in-a-lifetime delivery wrapped around an ordinary record. I liked the man. I voted in those years and I remember them. He was a president. That’s all — and it ought to be enough.