
CNN wants you scared again. On Monday the network ran an “exclusive”: US intelligence, it said, indicates Iran is developing plans to detonate a dirty bomb in Washington, aimed at senior Trump administration officials. On Jake Tapper’s program it ran under the chyron “MAJOR INTELLIGENCE ALERT.” If the script sounds familiar, it should. Glenn Greenwald dug up CNN’s version of the same headline from December 9, 2002 — that time it was an Iraq dossier hinting at a dirty bomb.
Now read CNN’s own article all the way through, because the scare deflates as you go. The sourcing is seven US officials, every one of them anonymous. The planning, in the article’s own words, looks like “an effort to give itself options rather than an indicator of an imminent attack.” On the most alarming claim — that bomb-making materials are already stashed inside the United States — CNN concedes its own sources are divided over whether the intelligence is even credible. Even CNN’s reporter, to her credit, explained on air that a dirty bomb is not a nuclear weapon: a conventional explosive wrapped in radioactive material, its damage measured in blocks. The caveats were all in the text. The television treatment shouted over every one of them.
Here is the part the critics have to answer, because it is real. Three weeks before CNN’s story, the Director of National Intelligence, Jay Clayton, warned in writing that Iran “has substantially increased efforts to target U.S. personnel” and that Iranian lethal plotting against U.S. citizens “have reached advanced stages.” The Gang of 8 in Congress was briefed on the threat environment. Cabinet officials really have moved onto military bases. The Wall Street Journal and Reuters reported American tankers pulled out of RAF Mildenhall in Britain in the wake of an Iranian threat. Iranian plotting against American officials is not a fantasy invented by a newsroom; it is documented, by people with names.
And the men who want the war finished say so out loud. General Jack Keane, the retired four-star general who argues the pro-war case on Fox, reacted to Clayton’s warning this way: “What we’ve been used to is Iran attacking with military means at U.S. bases in the region… but what we’re really talking about here is terrorist-type activities.” He pointed to Britain’s MI5, which he said has thwarted close to two dozen late-stage Iranian plots in five years. Former Vice President Mike Pence, on Meet the Press on Sunday, said the election was not lost because of the war: “It’s because we stopped short and didn’t finish it,” adding, “You don’t make peace with your enemy, you make peace with your defeated enemy.” Pence is a man who wanted this war and wants it finished, and his view should be weighed as exactly that — but the plotting record he points to is real.
Against all that, weigh what the officials running homeland security say now. Secretary Markwayne Mullin — who notes that in the daily briefings “we receive aspirational threats from Iran” every day and that President Trump “is target number one” — calls this planning “aspirational” and says it does not constitute a “new threat,” a remark the Daily Caller noticed sat nine paragraphs deep in CNN’s coverage. The White House says there are “no credible threats to the homeland.” And President Trump, asked today in the Philippines, warned that Iran would “pay a price the likes of which no country has ever paid before” if it attacked Washington. Tough talk in public; no new threat, says the man charged with the homeland. Both are on the record.
The one concrete precaution in CNN’s story is real too: Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has moved into military housing, and he confirmed it himself last week. But his stated reason was that a Wall Street Journal photograph let strangers geolocate his Georgetown home, against a background of Iranian threats — not that anyone had uncovered a specific dirty bomb plot against him. CNN folded the move into this story as though it were a response to this plot.
Now the timing, which is where Megyn Kelly’s segment today aimed its fire. On November 13, the director of Mossad, Roman Gofman, was in Washington meeting CIA Director John Ratcliffe — a meeting Axios reported, and the Jerusalem Post suggested Gofman was there pressing for a full resumption of the war. Three days later, CNN’s anonymous-source scoop landed. Kelly called the dirty bomb claim “bullshit,” and her question was the obvious one: what would Iran gain from an attack on Washington while Trump is pursuing diplomacy? Greenwald put the whole thing in one sentence: “The most amazing part of US government/media war propaganda is that they never bother to change the script a little bit, no matter how many times it’s been used over decades.” Saagar Enjeti of Breaking Points dug up the other half of the script — the phrase “dirty bomb” itself entered the language in 2002, when Attorney General John Ashcroft announced that Jose Padilla was going to smuggle one into the country. Padilla was never charged with any such plot.
And notice what else rode along inside CNN’s own article: the Attorney General, the Director of National Intelligence, and the CIA Director have written Congress demanding renewal of a surveillance authority that expired in June, citing “the heightened threat environment.” A good scare is useful for more than one thing.
Iran, for the record, denies all of it — its foreign minister called the story “Iraq War-style propaganda,” which is self-serving and also, this week, not entirely wrong. So here is where the record actually leaves us. Iranian plotting is real, and it is documented by named officials. The precautions are real. What rests on CNN’s seven anonymous officials alone — with no other major outlet independently reporting it — is the dirty bomb in Washington. That is the layer CNN sold under a “MAJOR INTELLIGENCE ALERT” chyron. I don’t know whether somebody in Washington fed CNN this story to soften the ground for restarting a war, or whether the network simply cannot resist a frightening headline sourced to people who won’t give their names. Either way, it is a sad commentary on what passes for journalism there. We have seen this movie before, and in 2002 it ended in Iraq. Believe the people who put their names on their statements — all of them, on both sides — over the ones who won’t.
Read more:
- CNN’s report — the November 16 exclusive
- CNN’s follow-up — Trump and Mullin respond, November 17
- Megyn Kelly’s segment — the criticism, in her own show’s clip
- Kelly’s other segment — the neocon push, with Pence