The Bishop Who Never Mentioned Jesus

Map of the Roman Empire in 180 CE, with Antioch in Syria in the Greek-speaking east
Photo: Doll91939, via Wikimedia Commons [CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain Dedication]

Around the year 180, the bishop of one of the oldest churches in the world sat down to write a defense of Christianity for a pagan friend — and produced three books in which Jesus of Nazareth never appears. Not once. No name, no birth, no teaching, no cross, no empty tomb. Theophilus of Antioch argued for God, for creation, for the prophets, for Christian morals, and even for the resurrection of the dead, and he did all of it without the man the whole faith is supposedly about. The books survive. Anyone can read them and check. That is what makes this worth your time: it is not a claim somebody is making about a lost text. It is a silence sitting in plain sight in a real one.

The bishop is Theophilus of Antioch — not the Theophilus addressed in Luke and Acts, who belongs to an earlier generation, but a church leader of the late second century. Eusebius, writing the first history of the church a century and a half later, lists him as the sixth bishop of Antioch, succeeding a man named Eros (Church History 4.20), and credits him with works against the heretics Marcion and Hermogenes as well (Church History 4.24). Those are lost. What survives, complete, is the To Autolycus: three books addressed to a pagan friend, a learned man who had been mocking Theophilus for calling himself a Christian. The books were written at different times, and the third cannot be earlier than 180, because it speaks of the emperor Marcus Aurelius as dead. Theophilus himself does not live much longer — though exactly how much longer is one of those things the reference books cannot agree on: his death is variously placed in 181, 183, or around 185. He tells us, in the work itself, that he was born a pagan, somewhere not far from the Tigris and Euphrates, and that he became a Christian by reading the Scriptures.

So much for the man. Now the check, because the check is the story. Run the name through the standard English translation of all three books and “Jesus” comes up exactly twice — and both times it is the wrong Jesus. In the long chronology that fills much of Book 3, Theophilus is working his way through the judges and kings of Israel, and he notes that when Moses died, “Jesus the son of Nun succeeded to his rule, and governed them 27 years.” That Jesus is Joshua; in Greek the two names are the same word, Iesous. Of Jesus of Nazareth there is nothing at all — no mention under that name, and no story attached to any other name either. What about “Christ”? The word never stands in the text as the name or title of a person. It survives only inside the word “Christian,” and Theophilus, when he explains that word in Book 1, chapter 12, explains it as a dictionary entry rather than a person: “we are called Christians on this account, because we are anointed with the oil of God.” Anointed — christos — is as close as he ever gets. The founder of the faith is present in his own defense of the faith only as the root of a Greek adjective, unpacked at the level of etymology.

The strangest moment comes when Autolycus puts the obvious question to him. Theophilus has been insisting that the dead will be raised, and his friend is unimpressed: “Show me even one who has been raised from the dead, that seeing I may believe.” It is the most direct invitation in all of early Christian literature. Here, surely, is where the bishop tells the story — the crucifixion, the third day, the witnesses. Instead, Theophilus first complains that Autolycus happily believes Hercules lives after burning himself and that Asclepius was raised after being struck by lightning, then points out that a displayed corpse would not convince him anyway. And then he offers his proofs. Consider, he says, the dying and rising of the seasons, of days and nights. Consider a seed of wheat cast into the earth: it dies and rots, then rises as a stalk. Consider the trees that bear fruit in season out of what was unseen. Consider, above all, the moon: “consider the resurrection of the moon, which occurs monthly; how it wanes, dies, and rises again.” He even appeals to Autolycus’s own body — you were sick once, you lost flesh and strength and beauty, and you got them back; where did the flesh go, and where did it come from? All of it is in Book 1, chapter 13, and all of it is about resurrection as a pattern woven into nature. Asked to produce one raised man, the bishop of Antioch produced agriculture and astronomy.

What fills the three books instead? In the first, an argument that God cannot be seen but can be known by his works, the way you know a ship has a pilot or a king exists by his laws; a long attack on the Greek gods, whose myths he recounts with relish; and the resurrection case just described. In the second, he goes through the Greek poets and philosophers to show they contradict one another, and then walks through the opening of Genesis day by day, treating it as straightforward cosmology — God made all things out of nothing, through his Word. It is in this second book, in chapter 15, that he gives us something genuinely historic: commenting on the three days of creation before the sun and moon existed, he calls them “types of the Trinity, of God, and His Word, and His wisdom.” That is the first surviving use of the word Trinity in Christian writing — and notice the cast list. God, his Word, and his Wisdom. The building blocks of later doctrine are all here, present and named, and the person they would eventually be organized around is not. The third book is given to defending Christian morals against the standard slanders of the day — that Christians shared their wives, committed incest, and ate human flesh — and to the chronology, in which Theophilus adds up the years from Adam to Marcus Aurelius and arrives at a total of 5,698 years for the age of the world. The point of the arithmetic is antiquity: Moses and the prophets are older than Homer and Plato, so the older and truer account is his.

Now the fairness, because this needs it. Theophilus was not a fringe figure or a heretic hiding in a corner. Antioch was one of the great sees of the early church — the place where, according to Acts, the disciples were first called Christians — and he held its bishop’s chair in a generation that also produced Justin Martyr in Rome and Irenaeus in Gaul. Justin, a working apologist writing to pagans a few decades earlier, named Jesus Christ on page after page; Irenaeus, writing at almost exactly the same time as Theophilus, built five books around him. Theophilus is the outlier, and any honest account has to say so plainly.

There are also innocent explanations, and they deserve to be put at full strength. To Autolycus is an apology: a defense addressed to an outsider, arguing from common ground. You do not open a case to a skeptical pagan, the argument runs, with the contested story; you open with the God you can argue for from nature, from antiquity, from morality, and you work inward. There is something to that. Every apologist chooses an order of battle, and Theophilus plainly chose creation and the prophets as his ground — the prophets were the credential he kept producing, the men whose predictions, he says, converted him. But the explanation only goes so far, because the control cases exist. Justin wrote apologies to pagans too, addressed to an emperor, and he found no difficulty starting from the common ground and naming Jesus within a page or two. Genre explains an emphasis. It strains to explain a total absence across three books, including the one moment — “show me even one who has been raised” — where the story was not merely available but requested.

What the silence actually shows is quieter than a scandal and more interesting. Around 180, there was as yet no fixed script for what a defense of Christianity had to contain. The faith had bishops, martyrs, heresy-hunters, and a word — Trinity — that Theophilus himself may have coined in print, but it did not yet have a checklist. A bishop could defend it from creation and antiquity, at length, with conviction, and simply never get to Jesus — and no editor, no colleague, no council stepped in to tell him a piece was missing. That is a fact about the second century that no creed preserves: how unsettled, how various, the thing still was while it was being built.

And the best part of it is that you do not have to take my word for any of this, or a documentary’s, or a scholar’s. The To Autolycus is not long, the translation is public domain, and the whole text sits online where a search box will do the counting for you. Search it for a name, and see what the name turns out to belong to. A silence you can verify yourself is worth more than a claim about one — so go and verify it.

Read more

The primary text — read it and run the search yourself:

Who Theophilus was — the bishop, the dates, and the dispute over them:

Leave a Reply