
I was trying to watch a show called Eternally Yours. It is supposedly a comedy — and I say supposedly with some feeling, because it is advertised as something like the best comedy on TV today. No. Not even close.
The setup is a family of vampires, and a perfectly ordinary guy — not a vampire — who is dating the daughter and gets folded into the household. On paper there is comedy machinery in that: the in-law problem, with fangs. A boyfriend trying to make a good impression on people who have been alive for centuries and have seen every boyfriend trick ever invented. A premise like that should be able to fall over and land on a laugh once in a while.
I am into the second episode of it — I am watching it on a streaming service — and I have not laughed once. I have not even smiled once. I just sit there looking at it, going: I don’t get this. Not “I don’t get the reference.” I don’t get what the joke was supposed to be. It is an awful program so far, and I use the word “program” loosely. I don’t even want to call it a show. A show implies somebody showed you something.
I don’t know where they got these writers from, but as far as I can tell it was not from writing comedy anywhere. Nothing lands, nothing builds, nothing is even interesting enough to carry you to the next scene while you wait for a joke that never comes.
What gets me is the billing. If a show sneaks up on you and turns out flat, that’s life. But when something is sold as the best comedy on TV today, it has made a promise, and two episodes is long enough to ask for the first installment on it. A drama can ask for patience. A comedy has to be funny now — this episode, this scene. That is the whole deal, and it is the one thing this show does not do.
I’m going to keep trying, because sometimes a show finds its legs late and I hate quitting on anything two episodes in. But I would not recommend it to anybody. If the third episode is like the first two, I’ll be done. Life is too short for a comedy you have to talk yourself into.