What Happened After October 7 — The Part You Didn’t Get, Part One

Destruction in Khan Younis, Gaza, June 11, 2024. Photo by Rawanmurad2025, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

For most of my life, I supported Israel the way a lot of Americans my age did — automatically. An ally in a bad neighborhood, a democracy surrounded by people who wanted it gone. When Hamas attacked on October 7, 2023, I understood striking back, and I understood going after the men who planned it. What I did not do, for far too long, was look hard at what came after.

I should have been doing this two years ago. That’s on me, and I’m not going to pretend otherwise. This post is the first in a series I’ll run about once a month: the documented record of the Gaza war and what grew out of it, gathered from every side I can find, with every number attached to whoever produced it — not blended, not averaged, not rounded into something nobody actually said. You read the evidence and decide for yourself. That’s the whole method.

In a very short time, Israel has gone from a beloved ally to somebody you want to hold at arm’s length — because they smell like what they’ve created: a corpse in the sun. I didn’t arrive at that sentence quickly, and I didn’t arrive at it from the sources you’d expect. I arrived at it from the record. Here is the record.

Start where it started. In the early morning of October 7, 2023, Hamas-led fighters crossed from Gaza into southern Israel by land, sea and paraglider, behind a barrage of thousands of rockets. They hit 24 communities, military bases, and the Nova music festival.

How many died that day is itself a first lesson in why this series attaches every figure to its maker. Israel’s initial official estimate was around 1,400. On November 10, 2023, the Foreign Ministry revised it to “around 1,200,” explaining that some of the unidentified dead had turned out to be attackers. Israel’s National Insurance Institute data, compiled by AFP that December, counted 1,139 dead: 695 civilians, including 36 children; 373 soldiers, police and other security personnel; and 71 foreign nationals. A British parliamentary commission counted 1,182. The UN Commission of Inquiry says more than 1,200, at least 809 of them civilians. The figures differ. They sit in the same neighborhood, and every one of them describes a massacre.

251 people were taken hostage into Gaza, by the standard Israeli count; the UN commission said at least 252. Some were already dead when they were taken.

Israel’s stated purposes, in its own words at the time, were two: destroy Hamas as a military and governing force, and bring the hostages home. The second of those was not in the security cabinet’s original aims — CNN reported last month that it was added about a week in, as the scale of the abductions became clear. By October 25, Netanyahu was pairing the two publicly.

Defense Minister Yoav Gallant ordered a “complete siege” on October 9: “There will be no electricity, no food, no fuel, everything is closed. We are fighting human animals and we are acting accordingly.” On October 28, as the ground invasion began, Netanyahu quoted the Bible: “You must remember what Amalek has done to you.” South Africa later read that line, in its case before the International Court of Justice, against the verse’s continuation — “slay both man and woman, infant and suckling.” Netanyahu’s office says he was talking about Hamas.

The United States’ answer came from President Biden on October 10: “We stand with Israel. We stand with Israel. And we will make sure Israel has what it needs to take care of its citizens, defend itself, and respond to this attack.” American ammunition and Iron Dome interceptors were already moving.

What the war then cost in Palestinian lives depends on who is counting, and the counters disagree — about the total, and about who the dead were. Here they are, separately, the way this series will always print them.

The Gaza Health Ministry publishes a running count of identified dead — names, ages, ID numbers — built from hospital and morgue records. The UN’s humanitarian office, OCHA, republishes the ministry’s totals with attribution; it keeps no count of its own. By that series: 42,010 reported dead at the war’s first anniversary, 40,717 of them fully identified. 45,936 by January 8, 2025. 47,161 by January 22, in the first ceasefire’s opening days. 67,173 identified at the second anniversary. And 74,618 reported in OCHA’s snapshot of November 4, 2026; the ministry’s own update a week later put it at 74,653. The ministry describes its figures as documented deaths — it has published the names of more than 72,000 of the dead — and its own reporting concedes the count is a floor rather than a ceiling: the war destroyed its computer systems, and registration had to be rebuilt by hand.

Israel’s own figures have mostly concerned the other side of the ledger — how many of the dead were fighters. In February 2024 the IDF said it had killed “over 13,000” people it classified as terrorists; it published no names with the claim. In May 2024, Netanyahu put the total dead at about 30,000 and split it himself: roughly 14,000 combatants and 16,000 civilians. No evidence was published with the split. In August 2025, The Guardian, +972 Magazine and Local Call reported on a classified IDF intelligence database from that May listing 8,900 named Palestinian fighters as dead or likely dead — 17 percent of the ministry’s toll at the time, which would leave about 83 percent civilians if both the database and the ministry’s total are taken at face value. The reporters noted the database omits fighters outside Hamas and Islamic Jihad. The IDF said the article’s numbers were incorrect. Herzi Halevi, the IDF’s chief of staff through most of the war, said after retiring that more than ten percent of Gaza’s population — about 220,000 people — had been killed or wounded.

Then, this past January, Israeli media reported something remarkable. In a background briefing, a senior Israeli military official told reporters the IDF believes the ministry’s toll is “largely accurate” — around 70,000 at that point, against the ministry’s 71,667 that week — with the breakdown between fighters and civilians still under review. The story ran in the Times of Israel, Haaretz and the Jerusalem Post, and then around the world. The next day, the IDF’s spokesman, Lt. Col. Nadav Shoshani, answered on X: “the details published do not reflect official IDF data.” Read that denial carefully. It disowns the briefing as official data. It does not say the figure is false, and the IDF has never published a toll of its own. Both halves of that story belong in the record, and there they are.

The ministry’s critics argue that its total folds in natural deaths, people killed by Hamas or by misfired rockets, and plain errors; one reconstruction, by the advocacy group HonestReporting, puts those categories in the thousands. The academic studies, using three different methods, point the other way. A capture-recapture analysis in The Lancet, matching three separate lists of the dead, estimated 64,260 traumatic-injury deaths between October 2023 and June 2024, when the ministry had reported 37,877 — an undercount of about 41 percent; a Wharton statistician’s critique argues a flaw in the method and puts the undercount closer to 7,800. A household survey of 2,000 Gaza households, published in The Lancet Global Health, estimated 75,200 violent deaths through January 5, 2025, with the ministry’s figure 34.7 percent below its central estimate — while the dead’s demographic makeup matched the ministry’s reporting closely; a 2026 critique in the same journal flagged irregularities in one interviewer team’s data. Demographers at the Max Planck Institute, modeling the ministry’s data together with other sources, estimated 78,318 direct conflict deaths through the end of 2024, and updated the work last fall to put the violent toll past 100,000 by October 2025; a follow-on analysis by the same team puts the first two years at roughly 115,000, inside an uncertainty range of 104,000 to 129,000.

One number you will see quoted does not belong in that list. A July 2024 letter in The Lancet projected that deaths attributable to the war, direct and indirect together, “could exceed 186,000.” It was a scenario, built on ratios drawn from other wars — a warning about what such wars do, not a count of what this one had done. It gets cited as a count anyway. It isn’t one.

The buildings are easier to count than the people. UNOSAT, the UN’s satellite center, compares imagery against the pre-war Strip: about 30 percent of all structures affected by January 2024; about 55 percent by May 2024; about 81 percent by October 2025; and in imagery from June 2026, 201,290 structures damaged or possibly damaged — some 82 percent — with 134,422 of them classified destroyed. Note the direction of that last step: the destroyed count rose after the ceasefire took effect. The World Health

Organization reports at least 94 percent of Gaza’s hospitals damaged or destroyed. A joint World Bank, European Union and UN assessment last spring counted more than 371,888 housing units destroyed or damaged, and put the cost of rebuilding at $71.4 billion over ten years. About 1.9 million people — nearly everyone in Gaza — have been displaced.

That’s the war, and what it cost, counted by everyone who counts it. Tomorrow at this same hour, Part Two: the hostages and the exchanges that brought them home, the argument over the word genocide in the words of the Israelis making it and the government answering it, where the ceasefire actually stands — and the older, quieter demolition system underneath all of it, which is where this series is headed.

Read more:

Counting the dead:
UN OCHA — Reported Impact Snapshot, November 4, 2026
Gómez-Ugarte, Chen et al. — “Accounting for uncertainty in conflict mortality estimation,” Population Health Metrics, 2025

Leave a Reply