Gnosticism: What the Losers Actually Said

Photo: Unknown author (attributed to Thomas), via Wikimedia Commons [Public domain]

Some time back, in a conversation that started with a livestream and ended with me ordering a book, I joked that the shortest post I could ever write on this subject would be two words long. “What is Gnosticism?” — “Nobody knows.” It got a laugh — and then stopped being funny, because the joke was nearly true for most of Christian history. For roughly seventeen centuries, almost everything the world “knew” about the Gnostics came from the people who had beaten them — their prosecutors, not their own books. Imagine knowing a man entirely from the closing argument of the lawyer who got him convicted, and you have the shape of the problem. This post is about how that happened, and about the day in 1945 when the defendants finally got to speak.

Start with the chief prosecutor. Irenaeus was bishop of Lyons, in Roman Gaul, and around 180 he produced the five-volume work we call Against Heresies — its full title is worth the space, because it tells you the verdict came before the evidence: The Refutation and Overthrow of Knowledge Falsely So-Called. His targets were fellow Christians — most of them sat in the same churches — who taught that salvation came through gnosis, a Greek word for knowledge: a direct, awakened knowing of the hidden God and of the divine spark buried in oneself. Irenaeus is, I will grant, a genuinely capable writer, which is part of what makes the performance so unpleasant. He catalogues his opponents’ doctrines at enormous length, and then, having set them up, he knocks them down with ridicule. When one teacher spun a system out of an unnameable first principle and its emanations, Irenaeus answered with a rival system of his own: in place of the aeons he installed a Gourd and Utter-Emptiness, who produced a fruit called a Cucumber, attended by a Melon — “the remaining multitude of the delirious melons of Valentinus.” It is funny, and it is also how you win an argument when the other side will never be allowed to publish a reply. I have read enough of the man to say what I said when this topic first came up around here: I don’t think I would have liked him very much had I known him in person.

The irony history played on him: his attack is the reason we knew anything detailed at all. Against Heresies is stuffed with summaries and quotations of the teachings he was burying — a brief so thorough it doubles as the only surviving archive of the defense. For some seventeen centuries, that was the record. And notice the word doing quiet work in every retelling: heretic. In the second century there was no finished orthodoxy, standing there fenced and settled, for these groups to deviate from — heresy itself started life meaning a school of thought, a choice. The Gnostic teachers were not rebels against an established faith; they thought they had it right, and in a great many places may have been the local majority. That last point is the thesis Walter Bauer argued in Orthodoxy and Heresy in Earliest Christianity (1934): in many regions, forms of Christianity later condemned as heretical were there first, and what we now call orthodoxy won largely by spreading outward from the church at Rome. Bart Ehrman calls it arguably the most important book on early Christian history of the twentieth century; Koester and Robinson built on it. It also has serious critics, and fairness requires naming them: H. E. W. Turner answered in 1954 that a stable core of belief ran beneath the variety, and others re-examining Bauer’s regional case studies found some leaning hard on silence — Egypt especially. The claim does not hold everywhere he pressed it — but the core of it does: nobody serious now teaches that a finished orthodoxy came first and heresy crept in afterward. The label came after the fight. That much, the fight’s losers could have told us, if anyone had kept their books.

Nobody did — with one buried exception. In December 1945, an Egyptian peasant named Muhammad ‘Ali al-Samman, digging for fertilizer near the town of Nag Hammadi in Upper Egypt, broke open a sealed jar and found thirteen leather-bound papyrus books: fifty-two texts in Coptic, translations of Greek originals mostly from the second and third centuries, copied out in the middle of the fourth. The usual reconstruction — plausible, though not proven — is that monks from a nearby monastery buried them after 367, when Athanasius of Alexandria’s famous list of approved scriptures made the unapproved dangerous to own. In the jar were the losers’ own books in their own words: a complete Gospel of Thomas, the Gospel of Philip, the Gospel of Truth, and the Apocryphon of John — so valued, apparently, that four copies of it survive. The winners write the history, and the losers are generally doomed by it. Nag Hammadi is the rare commuted sentence.

What the jar made possible, for the first time, was grading Irenaeus’s homework — and the honest report is that the grade is mixed, which is exactly why both the old dismissal and any romantic reversal are wrong. Where he can be checked, he was often working from real material. In the first book of Against Heresies (1.29) he summarizes a myth about Barbelo, first emanation of the unknowable God, and a boastful lower creator who announces, “I am a jealous God, and there is no god beside me.” The recovered Apocryphon of John matches that summary nearly point for point — he plainly had an early form of that very tradition in front of him, and scholars now use his summary to help reconstruct it. He was not inventing that one. But set beside the texts themselves, his method shows its other face. He took teachings from different teachers, in different places, arguing among themselves, and ironed them into a single absurd creed, the better to refute it once. Elaine Pagels — whose The Gnostic Gospels, the standard popular account of all this, sits on my own shelf — showed years ago that Irenaeus’s version of Valentinian teaching conflicts at points with another ancient witness’s excerpts from the Valentinian teacher Theodotus. The ancients did not agree about what these people believed; Irenaeus’s version is simply the one that got filed as the record. Then there is tone. Irenaeus sneered at the Valentinians’ Gospel of Truth, which “agrees in nothing with the Gospels of the Apostles.” A work by that name was in the jar, in Codex I — and whatever one makes of the scholarly argument over whether it is the very document he meant, what came out of the ground is no counterfeit life of Jesus competing with Matthew and Luke. It is a meditation, lyrical and strange, about ignorance as a nightmare that knowledge wakes you from. The monster turns out to be a sermon — and that gap, between the prosecutor’s description and the recovered thing itself, is this post’s whole subject in miniature.

So what did they actually believe? Here I will practice what I preach and keep my claim modest: when this topic first came up I described my own knowledge as a tablespoon, up from an eighth of a teaspoon, and a tablespoon does not fill a seminary course. The minimum honest sketch runs like this. Behind everything stands a true God so exalted as to be unknowable. The world we live in was not his direct work; it was made by a lesser, ignorant, or arrogant creator — the demiurge, in the Apocryphon named Yaldabaoth — which is why the world is the mess it observably is. Trapped in some human beings is a spark of the divine, a piece of the world above, and salvation is not a matter of believing the right propositions. It is waking up: knowing who you are, where you came from, and that this place is not your home. Jesus, in these texts, is characteristically the one who comes to deliver that knowledge. That is the shape. It is not the whole of it, because there is no whole of it — and that warning belongs inside the piece, not in a footnote. “Gnosticism” is a modern umbrella: the word itself was coined in the seventeenth century, and it covers groups — Valentinians, the so-called Sethians, and others — who differed from each other about plenty. Some scholars now argue the umbrella itself is the problem. Michael Williams’s Rethinking “Gnosticism” (1996) proposed dismantling the category altogether: the groups lumped under it shared no one creed and were not uniformly the world-denying ascetics of the standard description. Karen King’s What Is Gnosticism? (2003) traced how the category was built — first by the heresy-hunters, then by modern scholars who inherited their filing system. The other side deserves its hearing: Bentley Layton and David Brakke answer that a narrower use survives, because some ancient Christians were actually called — and may have called themselves — gnostikoi, “the knowers”; Brakke’s The Gnostics (2010) would keep the name for that one school and retire the bloated general version. Both positions are argued from the same recovered evidence, and the argument is not over — which is rather the point. The texts came back, and the conversation restarted.

What did not restart, mostly, is the picture carried around outside the scholarship. In the academy, 1945 changed the subject permanently. In the pews, the picture most people hold of the Gnostics is still Irenaeus’s — a parade of absurdities and delirious melons — because the winners’ institutions kept teaching the winners’ syllabus long after the evidence turned up, and because, in my opinion, church is more about feeling than facts, and no one’s Sunday depends on updating a file from the second century. The recovered texts are also, to be fair, genuinely hard reading: dense, mythic, alien. A jar in Egypt can change what scholars know; changing what everybody else assumes is slower work — ask anyone who has watched a correction chase a rumor.

The standing lesson of this blog, stated about as cleanly as any story I know: a movement judged for seventeen centuries entirely on its enemies’ testimony could be convicted of anything, and was. The remedy was never a better prosecutor. It was the primary sources — the defendants’ own books, in their own words, however strange those words turned out to be. It is the same principle this site applies to modern stories: go and look at the thing itself before you repeat what its opponents say it is. My Gospel of Thomas post from this fall lives on exactly this shelf — Thomas survives complete only because it was bound into Codex II of that same buried library. In 1945 the jar came out of the ground, and the Gnostics finally got their day in court. The verdict is considerably more interesting than “guilty of everything, in the words of their prosecutor.” We know a great deal more than we did — we just had to wait sixteen centuries for somebody to dig.

Read more

The scholarship:

  • Elaine Pagels, The Gnostic Gospels — the standard readable account of the Nag Hammadi find and what it changed (the book on my own shelf for this subject).
  • Pagels’s introduction, telling the discovery story in her own words: Introduction to The Gnostic Gospels, by Elaine Pagels

The prosecutor, in his own words:

The texts themselves:

Bauer’s thesis, and the argument over it:

  • Walter Bauer, Orthodoxy and Heresy in Earliest Christianity (1934; English edition 1971) — background on the thesis and its reception: Walter Bauer (BiblicalTraining Library)
  • H. E. W. Turner, The Pattern of Christian Truth (1954) — the classic reply, listed in the same entry’s bibliography above.

The fight over the word “Gnosticism” itself:

  • Michael A. Williams, Rethinking “Gnosticism” (1996), Karen L. King, What Is Gnosticism? (2003), and David Brakke, The Gnostics (2010) — all three sides summarized: Gnosticism — the problem with the word

Leave a Reply