The Talking Points Were for Sale

NVIDIA H100 graphics card
NVIDIA H100. Photo by 极客湾Geekerwan, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

If you follow conservative accounts on X, you saw the argument last December: selling Nvidia’s H200 chips to China was not a giveaway, it was strategy. American chips would dominate the world’s AI, and blocking the sales would only hand the market to Huawei. Reasonable people can hold that view. What nobody mentioned at the time was that some of the people making it were being paid by the click to make it.

This week The Midas Project, a watchdog group that tracks the AI industry, published how it found out. The posts promoting those articles carried shortened links, and the links were not innocent. Each one routed through a tracking redirect run for an influencer marketing firm called Urban Legend, so the firm could count which creator sent which reader where. Follow the fingerprints and a pattern falls out: more than 8,000 posts, from more than 80 different accounts, over more than a year.

WIRED had reported on Urban Legend before, doing the same kind of work. The firm’s own archived terms describe the arrangement plainly enough: creators are paid fees for “conversions” tracked through the company’s links. Pay per click, pay per sign-up. Advertising, in other words — except that almost none of the posts said so.

The Midas researchers counted at least two dozen AI-related campaigns in the traffic: defenses of the chip sales to China, attacks on “AI doomers,” and articles with titles like “Trump’s latest move to ensure American AI dominance.” The accounts that posted in support of the Nvidia exports carry about 14 million followers between them. The most recent campaign in the data ended on November 10.

The chips are not a detail. The H200 and its class sit under federal export controls for one reason: they are the machinery the AI race runs on, and Washington has treated their sale to China as a national-security question, not a trade question. Exporting controlled chips without a license is a federal crime, and people have gone to prison for moving far less capable hardware. That is what made the policy worth fighting over — the administration’s approval last December opened a licensed door where there had been a wall — and it is what made public opinion about that door worth buying.

Some of the money can be traced, a little way. One post actually disclosed itself, tagged as an ad for Build American AI, a dark-money group connected to OpenAI president Greg Brockman and tech investors Marc Andreessen and Ben Horowitz. Other campaigns promoted articles written by the senior policy advisor of Innovation Council Action, another dark-money group linked to David Sacks, the White House AI advisor.

Here is what the investigation does not show, and it matters. It does not show who paid for the chip campaigns specifically. The Midas Project says it found no conclusive link between Nvidia and any of this, and Nvidia has not commented. Urban Legend declined to comment — and, according to the report, changed its tracking domain the day after the researchers came asking.

The names need the same care. Urban Legend worked through a deep pool of influencers over the years, and that pool included Donald Trump Jr. and Kash Patel, now the FBI director. Both stopped posting the firm’s links in November 2024, and the majority of the firm’s campaigns had nothing to do with AI. Being in the pool is not the same as being in the chip campaign, and the distinction is worth keeping bright — especially this week, when the list is being read aloud on podcasts. Clint Russell’s Liberty Lockdown episode walks through the Midas data name by name, Riley Gaines among them, and a Texas conservative outlet has already counted its own state’s four: four influencers who pushed the chip articles, of whom exactly one labeled his post as paid.

Conservative media, to its credit, is not waving this off. Not the Bee covered the report straight. Tim Pool’s panel spent a segment on it. The story is being taken seriously by the very audience it was worked on.

Which is the point. Advertising is not a scandal; the internet runs on it. Undisclosed advertising dressed up as conviction is a different thing. The reader who trusted those posts last December thought he was watching an argument break out. He was watching a funnel — tracked to the click, paid on the conversion. If the case for selling the chips is a good one, it can survive being labeled as an ad. The people who chose not to label it are telling you what they thought of their own argument.

The investigation: “Who paid right-wing influencers to promote Nvidia chip sales to China?” — Model Republic (The Midas Project)

Coverage: “Paid influencers pushed Nvidia’s China chip sales while attacking AI critics” — Cybernews

Coverage: “Four Texas Influencers Pushed Nvidia’s China Chip Deal Through a Pay-Per-Click Firm” — Current Revolt

Discussion: “Right-Wing Influencers Paid to Push NVIDIA Chip Sales to China” — Liberty Lockdown, Clint Russell (YouTube)

Discussion: “The Chuds Are All In BIG BIG TROUBLE…” — Valhalla VFT, Nate Cornacchia (YouTube)

Leave a Reply