Which War Dates the Gospels?

P52, the Rylands fragment of John's Gospel
P52, the Rylands fragment of John’s Gospel — the oldest Gospel scrap we have. Photo courtesy of the John Rylands Library, via Wikimedia Commons (public domain).

Ask a textbook when the Gospel of Mark was written and you’ll get a confident answer: about AD 70. Ask how anyone knows, and the answer leans on one chapter — Mark 13, where Jesus predicts the Jerusalem Temple’s fall: “Not one stone will be left upon another.” Scholars generally read that as prophecy written after the fact, which dates the book to around the catastrophe it describes.

There’s just one problem. There are three catastrophes it could be describing, and they’re nearly a century apart.

Candidate one: the Caligula crisis, about AD 40. The emperor ordered his statue installed in the Temple — a “desolating sacrilege,” in the phrase Mark uses, borrowed from Daniel. Jews prepared to die rather than allow it; Caligula was assassinated before the order was carried out. Gerd Theissen argued that the little apocalypse Mark built his chapter around was written in this crisis — which would make the chapter’s core some thirty years older than the Gospel that carries it.

Candidate two: the Jewish War, AD 66–70. The textbook answer. Rome besieged Jerusalem and burned the Temple in 70, and Mark 13’s details — famine, false prophets, flight to the mountains — read naturally against it. This may well be right. It’s a reading, though, not a measurement: the chapter never names the year, the emperor, or the event.

Candidate three: the Bar Kokhba revolt, AD 132–135. A generation later, Hadrian refounded Jerusalem as a Roman colony with a temple to Jupiter on the sacred site — another desolating sacrilege, arguably a closer one. Hermann Detering made the case that the Synoptic apocalypse belongs to this crisis, which would put Mark decades later than the textbooks say.

Matthew and Luke, who copied and edited Mark, add details of their own — and Marcion’s gospel, the first one anybody bothered to list, may preserve an earlier form of Luke than the one in our Bibles, which tangles the timeline further. Run honestly, the scoring exercise doesn’t produce a winner. It produces a spread: the first Gospel could plausibly sit anywhere across a span of decades, depending on which war you think its author had just lived through.

Mark around 70 remains a reasonable conclusion. But “reasonable reading” is doing real work in that sentence — a surprising amount of what gets taught as the settled dating of the Gospels rests on interpretation of one apocalyptic chapter, and interpretation is exactly where scholars are free to disagree. They do.

Read more

  • For the Caligula reading: Gerd Theissen, The Gospels in Context (Fortress, 1991).
  • For the mainstream date and its reasoning: John S. Kloppenborg, “Evocatio Deorum and the Date of Mark,” Journal of Biblical Literature 124 (2005): 419–450.
  • For the Bar Kokhba case: Hermann Detering, “The Synoptic Apocalypse (Mark 13 par.): A Document from the Time of Bar Kochba,” Journal of Higher Criticism 7 (2000): 161–210.
  • For the Marcion question: Jason BeDuhn, The First New Testament (2013).
  • For the full scoring exercise on video: C.J. Cornthwaite, “Scholars date the Gospels by a war. They can’t agree which one.” (YouTube).

Leave a Reply