
I always thought that the knowledge that some of what is contained in the New Testament is pseudepigraphic was recent knowledge. This is a subject I have had an interest in for years. On and off, during those years, I have attempted to explore, to the best of my limited ability, the truth behind this book that so many place in such high regard. I don’t claim any expertise in any of this, and I depend on other sources — picked by me — to render a conclusion on the matter. But understand that although a lot of what I am writing here is undisputed by scholars, some of it is still contentious in that sphere.
Start with something simple. Almost none of the books in the New Testament tell you, inside the book itself, who wrote them. The names readers know — Matthew, Mark, Luke, John, Peter, Paul — come from tradition, attached later, the way a librarian writes an author’s name on the spine of a book that arrived without one. Sometimes the librarian was right. Sometimes we now know he wasn’t. And sometimes nobody knows, which is the part that gets left out of the sermon.
Authorship in the New Testament isn’t a yes-or-no question. It’s a spectrum. At one end are books scholars across the board accept as written by the man whose name they carry. At the other end are books nearly everybody in the field agrees were written by somebody else, in a famous name, after that man was dead. The ancients had a word for the practice — pseudepigraphy — and before anybody calls it a harmless custom, know that the early church punished it when they caught it. The church father Tertullian tells of a presbyter who composed a work about Paul, the Acts of Paul, and confessed he’d done it “out of love for Paul.” He was removed from his office anyway. Love was not a defense.
Why does any of this matter? Because “Paul said” and “Peter said” do real work in the church today. Sermons lean on those names. Doctrines lean on those names. If the name on the spine is wrong, the argument built on it deserves a second look. So let’s look — starting with Paul, because Paul is nearly half the book.
The seven nobody argues about
Thirteen of the New Testament’s twenty-seven books carry Paul’s name. That’s 48 percent of the shelf, by count — closer to a quarter of it by bulk, but either way, no other author comes close. Of those thirteen letters, seven are accepted as genuinely his by scholars across the spectrum, believers and skeptics alike: Romans, 1 Corinthians, 2 Corinthians, Galatians, Philippians, 1 Thessalonians, and Philemon.
Why these seven? The voice is consistent — same vocabulary, same sentence habits, same temper. They’re messy in the way real correspondence is messy: arguments half-finished, travel plans that change, personal grievances aired in public. Nobody forging Paul would invent Paul quarreling with Peter to his face, or admitting he didn’t remember exactly whom he’d baptized. And they’re early — Clement of Rome is already quoting Paul as an authority around AD 95, within a generation of the letters themselves. These seven are the measuring stick. Every other letter with Paul’s name on it gets held up against them, and that’s where the trouble starts. But before the trouble, a question of my own.
Who was the man who wrote them?
The seven letters prove a letter-writer existed. Somebody sat down and wrote Romans. But notice how much of what we “know” about that somebody comes from the letters themselves. That his name was Paul — the letters say so. That he was a Pharisee — he says so, in Philippians: “as to the law, a Pharisee.” That he was an apostle — his claim, pressed hard in Galatians, against people who evidently doubted it at the time. The one book that tells his life story, Acts, is anonymous, was written decades later, and — as we’ll see in Part Two — was written by an author whose own name is a guess.
Here is what we do not have. We do not have a single contemporary outside source that mentions him. Josephus, the Jewish historian who chronicled the period in enormous detail, never names him. No Roman record names him. Everything — everything — rests on the letters themselves and on what the church wrote afterward.
Now, I want to be fair about that, because fairness matters here. Consider George Washington. We know Washington existed the way we know almost nothing in history: letters to him and from him, government documents from his lifetime, books written by people who stood in the room with him. That’s evidence. But now put yourself two thousand years from now. The letters are gone — paper does that — and all that survives is a handful of writings about Washington written by people who never met him, generations later. How would the historians of that age prove there was a Washington? They couldn’t, the way we can. They’d have what we have for Paul: a tradition, some texts, and an argument.
There is a difference, and honesty requires it. Washington lived in a print culture — millions of copies of everything, and his paper still mostly vanished into attics and fires. Paul’s world copied by hand, on papyrus, in a population where perhaps three people in a hundred could read. The wonder isn’t that Paul’s record is thin. The wonder is that any of it survived at all. And we accept other ancient figures on thinner paper than Paul’s — Socrates wrote nothing at all and is known only through his students, and no one doubts there was a Socrates. So the letters prove a writer; the tradition gives him a name and a biography; and between those two things there is a gap that two thousand years is not going to close. Hold both at once and you’re about where I am.
The disputed three
Six letters remain. Three of them are genuinely argued about, and the argument is worth hearing from both sides, because both sides have one.
Ephesians has the weakest claim. Raymond Brown, whose introduction to the New Testament is about as mainstream as the field gets, estimated that around 80 percent of critical scholarship concludes Paul didn’t write it. Bart Ehrman’s numbers show why: Ephesians contains 116 words that appear nowhere else in Paul’s letters, and its sentences run to a length Paul’s never do — nine of its hundred-odd sentences pass fifty words, where Philippians manages one in a hundred and two. The theology has moved, too: believers are “already” raised and seated with Christ, where the Paul of the seven expects that in the future. The defense is real, though. Harold Hoehner wrote the largest modern case for authenticity, and his comparison with Galatians blunts the vocabulary argument more than Ehrman’s side usually admits. And there’s the secretary question — Paul used secretaries, and E. Randolph Richards has shown those secretaries were sometimes given a long rope. How long a rope explains Ephesians is the argument.
Colossians is the closest call of the thirteen. Brown put the field at roughly 60 percent against. But a survey of more than a hundred New Testament scholars at the British conference in 2011 went the other way — 56 for authenticity, 17 against, 36 honestly uncertain. The critical case, associated with Eduard Lohse, is that Colossians came from a circle of Paul’s followers at Ephesus around AD 80, preserving his teaching in their own words. Against that, some scholars have moved toward authenticity over their careers — Douglas Campbell is one. On Colossians, the evidence cuts both ways, and anybody who tells you it’s settled is selling something.
2 Thessalonians is the one where I have to correct the version of this argument you may have heard — including, I’ll admit, the version I expected to find. It is not true that most scholars reject it. James Dunn calls it a roughly even split, and that 2011 survey actually leaned toward Paul having written it, 63 to 13. The case against is still formidable, and it rests on one glaring problem: the two Thessalonian letters contradict each other about the end of the world. In 1 Thessalonians, the day of the Lord comes like a thief in the night — no warning, no signs. In 2 Thessalonians, it cannot come until a whole sequence of events happens first, including the arrival of a “man of lawlessness” who must be revealed beforehand. Same author, same subject, opposite timetables. Add that 2 Thessalonians warns its readers against a letter “as if from us” and then makes a point of signing itself in Paul’s own hand, and you can read that two ways: as a genuine man authenticating himself, or as a later writer protesting a little too much. Scholars are split because the evidence is split. That’s what an honest tie looks like.
Running underneath all three is the secretary defense, and it deserves its due in one place: Paul dictated. Styles vary. Men age. But the defense has to explain why vocabulary, sentence structure, and theology all moved together, in the same direction — away from the seven — and why that pattern happens to match what we’d expect if devoted followers wrote in his name after his death, which the early church demonstrably did elsewhere. It might still be Paul. It might. That word “might” is doing more work in this debate than any other.
The three nearly everybody gives up on
The last three — 1 Timothy, 2 Timothy, and Titus, the so-called Pastoral letters — are where the field’s patience runs out. A third of their vocabulary appears nowhere else in Paul, and much of it doesn’t show up in Christian writing until the second century. They describe a church with settled offices — bishops, deacons, enrolled widows — that looks like the church of a generation or two after Paul, not the improvised house assemblies of his lifetime. The travels they mention can’t be fitted into the journeys in Acts no matter how you bend the map. And when Marcion assembled the first known collection of Paul’s letters, around AD 140, the Pastorals weren’t in it. A small minority of scholars still defends them, usually by giving the secretary theory a harder push, and they should be heard — but it is a small minority, and on these three the burden has shifted.
Scholars call books like these “pseudepigraphal,” which is a polite, Greek way of putting it. The common word is forgery. I note the difference because of that presbyter Tertullian mentioned, deposed for writing about Paul “out of love.” The early church, which was closer to the practice than we are, did not consider the polite word adequate when it happened to them.
So that’s Paul — thirteen letters, seven solid, three argued, three surrendered, and a biography resting on the word of the letters themselves. Which raises the obvious question: if that’s the state of the evidence for the best-documented author in the New Testament, what about the rest of the shelf? Peter, the fisherman, and the most polished Greek in the book. Hebrews, a masterpiece with no author at all. Four Gospels with no names inside them, and a John who may not be the John you think. That’s Part Two.