
Part One yesterday laid out the war itself: the October 7 attack, Israel’s stated aims in its own words, and the toll, counted source by source and never blended. This second part is the human ledger and the argument — the hostages and the exchanges that brought them home, the word genocide in the mouths of the Israelis who use it and the government that answers them, where the ceasefire stands tonight, and the older system of demolitions underneath everything.
The hostages came home in installments, and that ledger is exact, so here it is exactly. In the first truce, in late 2023, Hamas released 105 hostages — 81 Israelis, 23 Thai nationals and one Filipino — and Israel released 240 Palestinian prisoners, 107 of them children, three-quarters of whom had not been convicted of a crime. In the January 2025 ceasefire’s first phase, by OCHA’s count, 25 Israeli hostages and 5 Thai hostages came home alive, the bodies of 8 more were returned, and 1,777 Palestinian detainees were released; the agreement as written had envisaged roughly 1,900 releases on the Palestinian side. The design figure and the count of what actually moved are two different numbers, and both are printed here because each is true of a different thing. In October 2025, by the Red Cross’s own completion report, the last 20 living hostages came home and the ICRC transferred 1,808 Palestinian detainees in the opening operation; OCHA’s wider count of everyone Israel released in that window is 1,968 — 250 prisoners serving life sentences and 1,718 Gazan detainees. Of the 28 deceased hostages, 27 were returned through the ICRC; the last, police officer Ran Gvili, was recovered by Israeli forces in January 2026. 360 deceased Palestinians were transferred back to Gaza. The ICRC’s cumulative ledger since October 2023: 195 hostages returned, including 35 deceased, and 3,472 detainees.
The sharpest criticism of all this has not come from Gaza, or from abroad. It has come from Israelis. In July 2025, B’Tselem — Israel’s best-known human rights organization — together with Physicians for Human Rights–Israel, published a report titled “Our Genocide.” Its director, Yuli Novak, said at the launch: “Nothing prepares you for the realization that you are part of a society committing genocide. But as Israelis and Palestinians who live here and witness the reality every day, we have a duty to speak the truth as clearly as possible: Israel is committing genocide against the Palestinians.” The report’s conclusion is that Israel is “taking coordinated action to intentionally destroy Palestinian society in the Gaza Strip.”
The Israeli government’s answer came the same day, through spokesman David Mencer, who called the allegation “baseless.” His argument, in his words: “There is no intent, (which is) key for the charge of genocide… it simply doesn’t make sense for a country to send in 1.9 million tons of aid, most of that being food, if there is an intent of genocide.” And: “We have free speech in this country but we strongly reject this claim.” The Foreign Ministry called the report “politically motivated,” “obscene” and “baseless,” and said Israel targets only Hamas. The IDF said it takes “unprecedented measures” to prevent harm to civilians while Hamas uses them as human shields. Those are the two positions, stated by their makers. This series prints both, because the argument between them is the story.
In September 2025, the UN’s Commission of Inquiry concluded that Israel had committed four of the five acts defined in the Genocide Convention, and that Netanyahu, Gallant and President Herzog had engaged in “direct and public incitement to genocide.” That is a UN body’s legal conclusion, attributed as such; Israel rejects it categorically, in the same terms as above. Even the UN’s secretary-general managed to anger both sides in a single speech, condemning the October 7 attacks “unequivocally” while saying they “did not happen in a vacuum,” and adding that Hamas’s appalling attacks could not justify “the collective punishment of the Palestinian people.” Israel’s ambassador demanded his resignation.
In the United States, the criticism now comes from both ends. Senator Bernie Sanders said in January 2024: “Israel has the absolute right to defend itself from Hamas’ barbaric terrorist attack on October 7, no question about that. But what Israel does not have a right to do — using military assistance from the United States — does not have the right to go to war against the entire Palestinian people.” In September 2025 he became the first US senator to say publicly that the campaign meets the legal definition of genocide. From the other end, Tucker Carlson: “Israel has definitely lost its morality. There’s no question about that… Killing innocents is never acceptable. Period.” And: “There’s no reason the United States should be sending any money at all to Israel.” And this month, Carrie Prejean — a conservative commentator who agrees with Bernie Sanders about almost nothing — posted a video of a Palestinian family’s home being demolished and laid the Republicans’ midterm losses at the feet of support for exactly this. When the same conclusion arrives from Sanders and from the America First right at the same time, it has stopped being a left-wing argument.
So where does it stand this morning? A ceasefire has formally been in force since October 10, 2025, under the president’s 20-point plan, endorsed by the UN Security Council. There has been no return to full-scale war. There has also been no peace. Israel has carried out near-daily strikes; Hamas fighters have kept attacking Israeli troops. The dead since the ceasefire, by source: Reuters counts more than 1,600 Palestinians and five Israeli soldiers; OCHA’s count stood at 1,613 this month; the Palestinian news agency WAFA says 1,622. This week, the Board of Peace’s second report to the Security Council faulted both Israel and Hamas for failing to meet their commitments, and warned that the ceasefire is “in danger of collapse.” Defense Minister Israel Katz said the same week that Israel will not withdraw until Hamas is dismantled. Hamas’s disarmament, the international stabilization force, the full withdrawal — the plan’s later phases have not happened. Israel has never declared the war over.
One more thing, because it is where this series goes next. The destruction in Gaza sits on top of a much older and quieter system in the West Bank and East Jerusalem: the demolition of Palestinian homes. It runs on two tracks. The punitive track: when a Palestinian is accused of an attack, his family’s home can be demolished or sealed, under Regulation 119 — a British Mandate emergency law from 1945. The people made homeless are the relatives; the accused is usually dead, captured or gone. Israel’s stated purpose is deterrence. In 2005, a committee appointed by the IDF’s own chief of staff concluded that no effective deterrence had been proven except in a few cases, and that the damage to Israel from the demolitions outweighed the benefit; punitive demolitions were halted for three years. At their Second Intifada peak, B’Tselem counted 628 housing units demolished punitively — 3,983 people made homeless over the acts of 333 suspects — and 47 percent of those units had never housed anyone suspected of anything. Israel’s own Foreign Ministry legal adviser, Theodor Meron, told the prime minister in a secret 1968 memorandum that the demolitions violated the Fourth Geneva Convention. The memo stayed secret for decades. The demolitions did not.
The administrative track is quieter: homes built without an Israeli permit, in places where UN trackers describe permits as almost impossible for Palestinians to obtain. In 2024, OCHA counted 1,768 Palestinian structures demolished, seized or sealed, and 4,265 people displaced — many of them owners ordered to tear down their own homes to avoid the fines. That track, house by house, is next month’s installment.
That’s the first installment. Everything in it is attributed to whoever produced it — Israeli officials and Israeli critics, the ministry in Gaza and the demographers in Rostock, the Red Cross and the satellite center. Where they disagree, they disagree here in the open. Later installments will take up the war in Lebanon, and the American aid ledger — what the support for all this actually consists of, beyond the headline number. For now, this is the record as far as we could gather it, from every side we could find. You decide what it adds up to. The point of printing it at all is the simplest one I know: stories like this one die of silence. This one stays alive as long as ordinary people keep telling it.
Read more:
The hostage exchanges:
ICRC — “Release and transfer operations under the ceasefire agreement completed,” January 29, 2026
The ceasefire today:
Reuters — “Trump’s Board of Peace faults Israel and Hamas for failure to end Gaza war,” November 18, 2026
Reuters — “One year on, Trump’s Gaza plan has not stopped Israeli fire or disarmed Hamas,” October 6, 2026
The genocide reports and the government’s answer:
Reuters, via TBS News — “Two rights groups are first Israeli voices to accuse Israel of genocide,” July 2025